That is the question.
Quite a few people I know already own Kindles, a good number of friends, my cousin, even my sister has one. Of the people I know who have one, I don't know a single person who has expressed regret in buying his or her Kindle. Evidently they are a handy tool. so I've been thinking about the possibility of buying one (since many of my friends have been prompting me, and telling me that I should), and seeing whether it would be worth the $160 or so that it would cost, assuming I got a case for it.
So, in order to make an accurate call I had to look at some of the advantages that are often mention of an eReader to see if it was worth it.
- You can have hundreds of books with you and not have to lug them around.
I've never found that to be a problem. I've never needed hundreds of books with me when I am traveling. One, maybe two would suit me just fine, and take up no more space than a Kindle would.
- You can buy and read a book in 60 seconds.
Again, never had a need to buy a book and then read it within that amount of time. Maybe for some that is an advantage, but I only see it as a cool, though non-vital feature.
- You can change the text size for easier reading if your eyes are getting tired.
It will probably be 40 years before I really struggle with that. When my eyes do get tired, it's not because the text is too small, it's because my head is too heavy. =)
- You can have the Kindle read to you with the "text-to-speech" option, if you get tired of reading.
I've listened to some of the "text-to-speech" and I can never get anything out of it because I am always too distracted by the way the words are being read. If I listen to an audio book, then it has to be a person reading it, and the reader has to be at least some what involved in the text, not just reading in a monotone voice, otherwise I don't get anything.
- You can browse the web with some eReaders.
From what I have read it is very frustrating to navigate around the web with an eReader, and slower too. Besides, I have a laptop for that.
- You can get most best sellers for $9.99, and other ebooks cheaper than paper books.
Cheaper is good, but according to my research this wasn't true. Not that you can't get ebooks cheaper than paperbacks, but that the books I needed were at most $1 cheaper for the ebook over the paperback, and sometimes up to $3 more expensive for the ebook vs. the paperback (and that is including the shipping).
It's not looking so good for the Kindle unfortunately. None of it's advertized advantages seem to be much of an advantage for my needs, and we haven't even covered the disadvantages yet. So, lets look as some of the things that I don't care for about eReaders.
- Though Amazon has about 950,000 books for the Kindle, it doesn't necessarily have the ones I need. When the Kindle first came out I always thought of it as a toy for avid book fans who enjoy sitting by the fire, reading their fiction books. So, I thought that it wouldn't have any of the books I need, but my sister did show me that they actually have more of my books that I realized. So, I searched, all the books that I could think of that I had bought and read recently, or will be reading in the near future, to see how many they had, and how much money I would have saved if I had bought an ebook instead of the "real" thing. This is what I found.
Our Passionate Journey: Frazier | x |
The Journey Continues: Frazier | x |
What is a Healthy Church?: Dever | √ (three dollars more) |
The Five Love Languages: Chapman | √ (one dollar cheaper) |
Holding Hands, Holder Hearts: Phillips | √ (30¢ cheaper) |
The Deliberate Church: Alexander | √ (two dollars more) |
More than Spectators: Downey | x |
Why Johnny Can't Preach: Gordon | √ (two dollars more) |
Tell the Truth: Metzger | x |
The Feasts of Israel: Scott | x |
The Christian & Social Responsibility: Ryrie | x |
Upright Down Time: Hand | x |
Why Johnny Can't Read: Flesch | x |
Boy Meets Girl: Harris | √ (one dollar cheaper) |
The Trellis and the Vine: Marshall, Payne | x |
Promise Unfulfilled: McCune | x |
The Measure of a Man: Getz | √ (50¢ cheaper) |
Of the 17 books I could think of, over half were not available, and I actually saved $4.20 by buying the "real" books as opposed to the ebooks.- I want to have a physical library of books. I want to be able to pull out a commentary of Job and lay it open on my desk. read some, then slide it to the side. Write some on my laptop, then look at my Bible, then open another commentary on that same passage. Compare the two commentaries. Open up my Hebrew Old Testament and examine a particular word. Sit back and muse for a while, then turn to my laptop again and type some more. Managing that with ebooks would be challenging, if not impossible.
- I like holding a "real" book. I've handled my roommate's Kindle, I've messed around some with my sister's Kindle and I much prefer holding a real book in my hands. I like turning pages. I like holding the book open and looking at it from the top and seeing how far along I am. It's just not the same with an eReader.
Kindles and other eReaders do have their benefits for some people, indeed a good number of people, but after doing the research, it does not appear as though I am one of those people. Maybe someday if my needs change, but as for now, I'm going to stick to killing trees. ;-)
Still old fashion,
Tim
